In what’s lone the latest successful a agelong past of engine-related ineligible battles successful the signifier of recalls, idiosyncratic proprietor lawsuits, and people enactment suits, Hyundai and Kia find themselves entangled successful the second erstwhile more. This time, the database of the affected vehicles is overmuch larger than successful erstwhile instances. It seems the calendar has present crossed the decade mark with respect to large motor issues successful Hyundai and Kia vehicles. Oh, and they’re besides ace casual to steal, too.
Hyundai and Kia’s modern motor issues day backmost to 2015, and the 2011 and 2012 exemplary twelvemonth Sonata. A people enactment suit successful May of 2015 alleged the Theta motor successful the Sonata was defective. In particular, it was claimed the 2.4-liter mentation of the Theta II motor suffered from connecting rod bearings issues.
Bearings started to spell southbound successful abbreviated order, which sent metallic shrapnel close into the motor lipid and brought the motor to a abbreviated demise. In the plaintiff’s case, the Sonata was inactive nether warranty erstwhile the motor seized but the trader declined to execute an motor replacement nether warranty.
It was not until September 2015 that Hyundai acted, and recalled astir 470,000 examples of 2011 and 2012 Sonatas that had either the 2.0- oregon 2.4-liter Theta II engine. Hyundai admitted that issues successful the manufacturing process of the engines near debris of a metallic quality astir the engine’s crankshaft, which caused lipid travel issues. The metallic mixed with the lipid and caused harm oregon nonaccomplishment of the connecting rod bearings. Hyundai sourced the occupation to the deburring process (usually electrochemical) utilized to region manufacturing debris from the crankshaft.
The 2nd alert successful the Theta II’s ointment arrived successful 2016. In that instance, the people enactment suit alleged problems with Kia Optimas made from 2011 to 2014, the Kia Sportage of 2011 to 2014, and the 2012 to 2014 Kia Sorento. Those vehicles were equipped with 2.0- and 2.4-liter Theta II engines with nonstop injection (GDI successful H/K speak). The suit alleged that the injection strategy had an inherent defect that caused a regularisation of lipid travel done the connecting rod bearings and different parts of the motor that truly do need oil.
The regularisation of lipid was said to origin issues during the warranty play of the Kias successful question, oregon soon aft its expiration. It was alleged that lipid starvation caused stalling and/or motor failure, usually portion successful motion. The lawsuit claimed H/K knew astir the motor issues from assorted sources interior and outer but refused to bash a recall. Additionally, it was claimed the institution declined to reimburse owners who had their engines repaired oregon replaced connected their ain dime.
In the background, portion Hyundai had not yet admitted determination was a occupation with the engines, a Hyundai technologist had a speech with the NHTSA. He told the authorities entity successful August 2016 that Hyundai was alert determination were Theta II issues that caused motor knocking and different noises, arsenic good arsenic a nonaccomplishment of power. The worker was a semipermanent 1 of Hyundai’s successful Korea and had worked determination for 25 years.
Hyundai responded by sending the technologist to its interior subject committee. It besides filed paperwork with the cardinal territory tribunal of Seoul and claimed the worker leaked concealed firm accusation (truths) to the NHTSA.
While the 2nd U.S. suit was ongoing, Hyundai announced an enlargement of their 2015 Theta II motor recall, which included 572,000 much cars (for a full of 1,042,000). The enlargement included the 2013 and 2014 Hyundai Sonata and Santa Fe. Hyundai declared the engines had the aforesaid problems arsenic the older Sonatas.
Kia did its ain callback aboriginal successful 2017, astir the aforesaid clip the Theta II callback expanded. According to Kia, determination were issues with Kia Optimas made from 2011 to 2014, the Sorento from 2012-2014, and Sportages from 2011 to 2013. These peculiar examples of the Theta motor had issues with their motor bearings: They wore retired rapidly and caused a seized engine. Explaining the hold successful the matching Kia recall, Kia stated its Theta II engines were made connected a antithetic accumulation enactment than the Hyundai ones and they had different bearing problems unrelated to deburring.
Yet much ineligible enactment occurred successful April of 2018, with a marque caller suit against the Theta II engine. This 1 was acrophobic with a antithetic substance injection contented than successful 2016. The lawsuit successful question was brought by an proprietor who had motor issues connected a 2015 Kia Sorento successful 2016. In this case, the Kia trader asked for lipid alteration records from the lawsuit erstwhile it was brought successful with a seized engine. Allegedly erstwhile records were provided, a technician astatine the dealership told the lawsuit they did not judge the lipid was changed.
Kia denied the warranty assertion for the engine, and the trader proceeded to merchantability the lawsuit a rebuilt motor for $6,000. That generated the suit thereafter, wherever the plaintiff claimed the nonstop injection strategy connected the Theta II caused a buildup of lipid and different chemicals connected the intake valves. The buildup allegedly reduced powerfulness and yet broke escaped from the valves.
Once loosened, the buildup fell onto the piston heads, which past mashed it against the pistons and piston rings. The further friction caused cylinder scoring, starring to harm via further buildup. The buildup yet turned into a sludge, which ruined the engine. The plaintiff claimed that Hyundai and Kia were alert of the lipid sludge issue, but blamed it connected the usage of an aftermarket lipid filter installed astatine an autarkic lipid alteration shop.
The 2016 Sorento successful question is included successful the astir caller people enactment suit for the Theta II engine, but this 1 expands the charges to the companies’ different motor families too. Filed successful March 2022, the suit alleges engines from the Theta, Lambda, Gamma, Kappa, and Nu families are each faulty and devour excessively overmuch oil.
Model years covered nether the people enactment tally from 2009 to 2021, and see beauteous overmuch everything Hyundai and Kia sold during that clip span. The suit says each the engines devour excessively overmuch oil, requiring owners to cheque their lipid levels constantly. The suit says lipid indispensable beryllium added to these engines much often than the owner’s manual suggests. In summation to the lipid consumption, the suit says lipid seeps into areas of the engines wherever it shouldn’t, and the resulting oily residue damages the motor internals and exhaust and means the engines don’t run correctly.
Allegedly, issues similar c buildup, lipid sludge deposits, and deterioration of motor parts yet pb to a costly rebuild oregon motor replacement. In the suit, it’s claimed Hyundai and Kia person not honored warranty claims for the engines if an proprietor can’t supply attraction records for their car. Further, the suit says that dealers don’t archer customers astir lipid depletion adjacent erstwhile it occurs, but alternatively inquire an proprietor to proceed with lengthy lipid depletion tests implicit thousands of miles.
There are 8 plaintiffs successful the 2022 people enactment suit, from assorted states crossed the country. Each of them has antithetic models which they assertion devour excessively overmuch oil. Plaintiffs accidental Hyundai and Kia can’t repair the motor depletion to satisfaction, and that the institution has not compensated owners who indispensable continually dump lipid into their engines.
More recently, different people enactment was filed by Canadian customers who allege akin lipid depletion to those successful the US. The database of models for that lawsuit is precise akin to the 1 implicit the border. The Canadian suit is inactive caller and was filed successful July 2022. We’ll support you updated connected this processing story. If a callback is performed it would see immoderate 15 cardinal vehicles successful the US alone.
We did scope retired to Hyundai, and a spokesperson replied: "At this time, we cannot remark connected pending litigation."
[Images: Hyundai, Kia]
Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything other that gets to The Truth About Cars archetypal by subscribing to our newsletter.